The band around each method

How far off each forecast landed, by months ahead

The whole book, every month-end close from December 2021 to September 2026, each forecast against what billed. Switch between the methods under the title.

Method

Average miss = the forecast against what billed, averaged over every close that can be checked that far ahead (negative is under). The shading is the average plus or minus one standard deviation. Typical size = the size of the miss, whichever way, averaged.

Each view shades one method; Power Law’s average miss is the dashed line in the others, for comparison. A distance shows only where 12 or more closes stand behind it. Straight Line and Seasonal stop at 12 months: a December close reaches no further, so past 12 months they would be read from a different set of closes.

Show the numbers

Straight Line

Straight Line: Average missStraight Line: LowStraight Line: HighStraight Line: Typical sizeStraight Line: ClosesPower Law, for comparison: Average missPower Law, for comparison: LowPower Law, for comparison: HighPower Law, for comparison: Typical sizePower Law, for comparison: Closes
1 month ahead−1.7%−5.6%+2.1%3.6%58−0.1%0.6%58
2 months ahead−1.5%−5.4%+2.3%3.6%570.0%1.0%57
3 months ahead−1.2%−5.4%+3.0%3.7%56+0.2%1.3%56
4 months ahead−0.7%−5.2%+3.8%3.7%55+0.4%1.7%55
5 months ahead−0.1%−4.9%+4.7%3.8%54+0.6%2.1%54
6 months ahead+0.4%−4.7%+5.6%4.1%53+0.8%2.4%53
7 months ahead+0.9%−4.6%+6.3%4.3%52+1.0%2.7%52
8 months ahead+1.2%−4.5%+6.9%4.6%51+1.2%3.0%51
9 months ahead+1.5%−4.5%+7.5%5.0%50+1.4%3.3%50
10 months ahead+1.7%−4.8%+8.2%5.5%49+1.6%3.5%49
11 months ahead+1.8%−5.1%+8.6%5.9%48+1.9%3.8%48
12 months ahead+1.7%−5.4%+8.9%6.0%47+2.1%4.1%47
13 months ahead+2.1%4.1%46
14 months ahead+2.1%4.0%45
15 months ahead+2.2%3.9%44
16 months ahead+2.1%3.7%43
17 months ahead+2.1%3.5%42
18 months ahead+2.1%3.3%41
19 months ahead+2.0%3.0%40
20 months ahead+1.9%2.7%39
21 months ahead+1.8%2.5%38
22 months ahead+1.6%2.3%37
23 months ahead+1.6%2.3%36
24 months ahead+1.9%2.4%34

Sample data: an invented payments portfolio, no client data.